Ready to start?
Get Evelyn Hugo on Amazon →Taylor Jenkins Reid's 2017 novel became the defining BookTok novel of the early 2020s. Our verdict: does the Hollywood glamour and heartbreak actually live up to the hype? Is the narrative structure as clever as people claim, and does the ending land?
• Love character-driven stories about complicated, morally grey women
• Want a book that makes you genuinely cry and feel the loss
• Enjoy Hollywood Golden Age glamour with real emotional substance underneath
• You want a twist that actually reframes the whole novel rather than just shocking you
• Primarily read for prose quality — Reid writes to serve story, not sentence-level beauty
• Find morally complex protagonists who make terrible choices unsympathetic rather than compelling
• You've already read it and want something equally good — there are few true equivalents
The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo became a BookTok phenomenon for the same reason most books do: it gives readers exactly what they want while also giving them something they didn't know they needed. The "what they want" is glamour, drama, and a story about a beautiful woman with a scandalous past. The "what they didn't know they needed" is a genuinely honest treatment of a bisexual woman in mid-20th century Hollywood who made every compromise she had to make and never stopped paying for them.
Evelyn Hugo is one of the great creations of 21st-century popular fiction. She is vain, calculating, ruthless, and loving all at once. Reid never softens her or apologises for her. The novel understands that you can love someone deeply and be genuinely terrible to other people, and it refuses to resolve that contradiction into a lesson. Evelyn doesn't become a better person. She becomes more herself.
The frame narrative — journalist Monique Grant interviewing the reclusive Evelyn for her authorised biography — is the weakest element. Monique's personal subplot feels underbaked compared to Evelyn's story, and most readers will find themselves skimming her sections to get back to the main event. This is a structural problem that Reid clearly knows about but couldn't fully solve: you need the frame to make the twist work, but the frame is less interesting than what it frames.
The seven husbands structure is mostly a clever piece of marketing that the novel delivers on. Not all seven are equally interesting, but the device gives Reid permission to skip across decades without it feeling like an info-dump. The years accumulate the way a real life does: unevenly, with certain periods lingering and others passing in a paragraph.
The novel's real subject is Evelyn's relationship with Celia St. James, the actress she loves throughout her life and cannot be with publicly. Reid builds this relationship with real craft — the early flirtation, the years of proximity and distance, the compromises, the loss. By the time the emotional climax arrives, it lands with a weight that most novels spend 400 pages trying to earn and never achieve. This is why people cry at this book. It's not manipulative. It's earned.
The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo is not a perfect novel. The frame is weaker than the portrait, the prose is functional rather than beautiful, and a few of the seven husbands barely register. But Evelyn herself is a creation of genuine greatness, and the love story at the novel's centre is devastating in all the right ways. The hype is real. Read it.
Score: 9.2/10. One of the best popular novels of the 2010s. Essential.
Free newsletter
Weekly reading picks, new author guides, and hidden gems — straight to your inbox.