Book Verdict

Is Six of Crows Worth Reading?

Ready to read it?

Get Six of Crows on Amazon →

Leigh Bardugo's heist duology — six morally grey criminals attempting the impossible job in a fantasy world built on trade and crime. The best YA fantasy of the decade.

9.2
Out of 10
Plot
9.5/10
Characters
9.5/10
World-Building
8.5/10
Pacing
9/10
Prose
8.5/10

What Works

  • Six fully-realised characters with distinct voices, backstories, and moral complexity
  • The heist plot is constructed with thriller-level precision — set-up, complication, reversal, payoff
  • Ketterdam (fantasy Amsterdam) is the most vividly realised setting in the Grishaverse
  • The enemies-to-lovers slow burn between Kaz and Inej is deeply earned
  • Doesn't require prior knowledge of Shadow and Bone to work

What Doesn’t

  • The multiple POV chapters require patience in the first 100 pages
  • Readers who haven't read Shadow and Bone will miss some Grisha context
  • Crooked Kingdom (the sequel) ends on a devastating note not all readers will forgive

Who Is This For?

Read It If You…

• You want fantasy with a tight plot rather than sprawling lore-building

• Ensemble casts with morally grey protagonists are your thing

• You loved the Ocean's Eleven structure applied to fantasy

• Enemies-to-lovers tension is your preferred romance

Skip It If You…

• You need a light, optimistic read — this is darker than it first appears

• You want magic as a central plot element rather than backdrop

• You prefer linear single-POV narratives

Why It Works

Six of Crows solves a problem most YA fantasy struggles with: it has a plot that actually demands the characters exist. Kaz Brekker's heist — breaking into the most impenetrable prison in the world — requires exactly these six people, with exactly their skills and histories. When Bardugo reveals backstory through flashback, it's because the backstory explains something we need to understand in the present. This is good construction.

The characters are extraordinary. Kaz Brekker is one of the most compelling protagonists in genre fiction — not because he's sympathetic in the conventional sense, but because his damage is structural and precise. Inej Ghafa is his counterweight. Their relationship is the novel's emotional engine, and Bardugo is patient with it in ways that lesser authors would not be.

Where It Wobbles

The opening chapters are slower than the rest of the novel — the assembly of the team requires some exposition. And readers who go in expecting the Grishaverse magic system to be central will find it secondary to the heist mechanics. This is a feature for some readers and a disappointment for others.

The Verdict

The best book Leigh Bardugo has written. One of the best YA fantasy novels of the decade. If you read fantasy at all and haven't read this, read it. If you've only read Shadow and Bone, you need to know that this is significantly better.

Score: 9.2/10. Essential. Read Crooked Kingdom immediately after.

Common Questions

No — Six of Crows is designed to work as a standalone entry to the Grishaverse. Shadow and Bone adds context but is not required.
It's published as YA. The darkness is real — violence, trauma, moral ambiguity — but handled with the directness that defines the best YA rather than the gratuitousness of adult dark fantasy.
The show is good and incorporates Six of Crows characters in Season 1. It diverges from the books significantly, so treat it as a companion, not a substitute.
Read it immediately. The duology should be treated as one long novel rather than two separate books.
Author Guide
Leigh Bardugo Reading Order
Reading List
Best YA Fantasy Books
Genre Hub
Fantasy
Blog
Reading Guides