All Riley Sager Books in Order
01
Final Girls
Quincy Carpenter survived a massacre at Pine Cottage — the only survivor. She's lived a careful, normal life since. Then one of the other 'final girls' turns up dead and a second appears on her doorstep. Sager's debut is a twisty, relentless thriller that announced a major new voice in horror-adjacent suspense.
ThrillerHorror AdjacentDebut
02
The Last Time I Lied
Fifteen years after three girls vanished from Camp Nightingale, Emma is returning — this time as a counsellor. Atmospheric summer camp horror with the kind of dread that builds in daylight. Sager's second book cemented his reputation for clever misdirection.
ThrillerHorrorSummer Camp
03
Lock Every Door
Jules is thrilled to score an apartment-sitting gig at the exclusive Bartholomew building. Then a neighbour disappears. Then another. Sager's Rosemary's Baby-adjacent thriller is his most atmospheric — a locked-room mystery with a gothic building at its heart.
ThrillerGothicPsychological
04
Home Before Dark
Maggie Holt inherited Baneberry Hall — the house her family fled 25 years ago after her father wrote a bestselling memoir about its horrors. She doesn't believe the haunting was real. But as she renovates, she begins to wonder. Dual-timeline, unreliable memory, gothic atmosphere.
ThrillerGothicHaunted House
05
Survive the Night
Charlie is desperate to get home for Thanksgiving. She accepts a ride from a stranger — and starts to wonder if he's the campus killer. Set almost entirely in a car, Survive the Night is a pressure-cooker thriller about the stories we tell ourselves to feel safe.
ThrillerRoad TripClosed Room
06
The House in the Pines
Not a Sager book — but Ana Reyes's debut is the closest successor to Final Girls' energy: a woman returning to confront a dark past, a mysterious man, and a mystery that unravels beautifully. Recommended for Riley Sager fans.
ThrillerRead NextSimilar Vibes
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best Riley Sager book to start with?
Final Girls is the natural starting point — it's his debut and still his most praised. Lock Every Door is arguably his best overall (the atmosphere of the Bartholomew building is unforgettable), but Final Girls sets the tone for everything that follows.
Are Riley Sager books connected?
No — each book is a standalone thriller with new characters and settings. You can read them in any order. Publication order (Final Girls → The Last Time I Lied → Lock Every Door) is a good choice if you want to see his craft develop, but it's not required.
Is Riley Sager horror or thriller?
He occupies the space between the two. His books have gothic atmosphere and horror tropes (haunted houses, camp killers, building curses) but they resolve as thrillers with rational explanations. Perfect for thriller readers who want a darker edge, or horror fans who prefer psychological dread to gore.
Who is Riley Sager really?
Riley Sager is a pen name for Todd Ritter, a journalist and author from New Jersey. He adopted the pseudonym for the genre shift into darker thriller territory.